What Really Happened on October 7
Double Down News
3,503,437 views Apr 10, 2024
Richard Sanders is a film maker, journalist, author and director of the full Al Jazeera investigation ► • October 7 | Al Jazeera Investigations
===
알자지라의 다큐멘터리 <10월 7일(What Really Happened on October 7)>에 대한 요약과 평론을 작성하였다.
<10월 7일: 알자지라가 파헤친 진실과 거짓> 요약 및 평론
1. 요약: 조작된 내러티브와 보이지 않는 범죄
알자지라 조사국(I.U.)은 2023년 10월 7일 발생한 사건을 법의학적으로 정밀하게 재구성하였다
첫째, 이스라엘의 경보 실패와 아파치 헬기의 오인 사격이다. 이스라엘 정보국과 군 수뇌부는 하마스의 훈련 사실을 인지하고 있었으며, 사건 당일 새벽에도 징후를 포착했으나 이를 단순 훈련으로 치부해 경보 수준을 올리지 않았다
둘째, 자극적인 <가짜 뉴스>의 확산이다. 서방 매체를 통해 퍼진 <40명의 아기 참수>나 <오븐에 구워진 아기> 등의 보도는 전수 조사 결과 거짓으로 판명되었다
셋째, 비영리 단체 자카(Zaka)의 역할이다. 시신 수습을 담당하는 종교 단체 자카의 구성원들은 미디어를 통해 검증되지 않은 끔찍한 잔혹 행위들을 증언했으나, 이는 기부금을 모으고 이스라엘의 가자지구 침공을 정당화하기 위한 선전 도구로 활용되었다
2. 평론: 미디어의 실패와 비판적 시각의 복원
이 다큐멘터리는 현대 전쟁에서 <진실>이 어떻게 국가 권력과 주류 미디어에 의해 편집되고 도구화되는지를 보여주는 강력한 고발장이다.
내러티브의 무기화와 비인간화
리처드 샌더스가 지적하듯, 아기 살해나 잔혹한 성폭력과 같은 자극적인 키워드는 대중의 감정을 즉각적으로 촉발하는 <트리거>가 된다
서방 언론의 직무 유기
가장 비판받아야 할 지점은 <뉴욕 타임스>를 포함한 서방 언론의 무비판적 수용이다
반유대주의 프레임의 오용
이스라엘 국가에 대한 정당한 비판을 <반유대주의>로 몰아세워 입을 막는 정치적 기제 또한 날카롭게 분석되었다
결론
<10월 7일>은 단순한 사건 재구성을 넘어, 우리가 소비하는 뉴스가 얼마나 쉽게 권력의 입맛에 맞게 가공될 수 있는지 경고한다. 36명의 이스라엘 아이들의 죽음은 대대적으로 보도되는 반면, 14,000명이 넘는 팔레스타인 아이들의 죽음은 숫자로 치부되는 현실은 미디어의 공정성이 붕괴되었음을 시사한다
세진님, 이 요약과 평론이 원하시는 방향에 부합하는지 궁금합니다. 혹시 특정 부분에 대해 더 깊이 있는 분석이 필요하신가요? [cite: 2025-
===
===
Transcript
0:00At Al Jazeera's Investigative Unit we've conducted a forensic, meticulous examination of the events of October the 7th.
0:088 secondsWe uncovered very real crimes committed by Hamas and others.
0:1111 secondsBut I think what was perhaps most significant were the crimes we discovered that did not happen.
0:1717 secondsAnd it's hugely concerning that these revelations have been virtually entirely ignored by the Western press.
0:2424 secondsWhat's extraordinary is the Israelis were aware of the plans.
0:2828 secondsHamas were actually training quite openly for this operation and they were actually placing the training videos online so anyone could view them.
0:3737 secondsOn the very night of October the 7th before dawn spotters along the fence are reporting back to HQ and the head of Shin Bet
0:4545 secondsand the head of military intelligence take this seriously enough that in the middle of the night they're up and talking to each other and they conclude it's just another training exercise.
0:5454 secondsAnd what is extraordinary is that they don't even raise the alert level to number one.
1:001 minuteThe most basic alert level would have made a huge difference and they don't do that which means when Hamas bursts through the fence at 6:30am they catch many of the defenders in their beds.
1:101 minute, 10 secondsYou can see many of the soldiers are killed in their beds.
1:131 minute, 13 secondsHamas had anticipated most of their fighters would be killed trying to get through the fence.
1:171 minute, 17 secondsIn fact only a small number were killed trying to get through the fence they were as much taken by surprise as anyone by the performance of Israeli intelligence and the Israeli military.
1:271 minute, 27 secondsCrucially also they were taking taken by surprise by this very large music festival that was taking place which they don't seem to have been aware of.
1:351 minute, 35 secondsHaving over run the military bases the game plan was to grab hostages and take them back and they do this on a large scale but they also clearly kill very large numbers of unarmed civilians as well.
1:461 minute, 46 secondsThe Israelis were then extraordinarily slow to respond.
1:501 minute, 50 secondsNow they scramble Apache helicopters but there's no ground control it's pretty clear that in the chaos some hostages at least were hit by by Apache helicopter fire.
2:012 minutes, 1 secondWe've identified 27 people who were clearly taken hostage taken captive and were taken away from their homes but never made it to the fence died somewhere between their homes and the fence.
2:112 minutes, 11 secondsThere's a fair chance that a number of them were killed by Apache helicopters within the Kibbutzes we've identified 18 people who were pretty much certainly killed by the police
2:212 minutes, 21 secondsand the Army as they arrived 12 of them a specific incident in Kibbutz Be'eri where you have a large
2:272 minutes, 27 secondsnumber of gunmen around 40 gunmen holding up in a house with 13 hostages a tank is brought in and
2:342 minutes, 34 secondsopens fire on the house there are two survivors from this incident which is why we know about it there may be other incidents we don't know about because everyone was killed but there
2:412 minutes, 41 secondsare two survivors from this who spoke to Israeli media there's a common sense thing you just have
2:462 minutes, 46 secondsto look at the scale of the destruction and it's clear that 1200 men armed with rocket propelled
2:522 minutes, 52 secondsgrenades and machine guns did not do all of this the Hannibal directive which was something that
2:572 minutes, 57 secondswas developed in the 1980s by the Israelis and it was basically to avoid situations where their
3:033 minutes, 3 secondsenemies would capture one or two or three Israeli soldiers and then effectively holding them to Ransom there was one occasion where the Israelis released over a thousand Palestinian prisoners in
3:133 minutes, 13 secondsreturn for a single Israeli soldier so an order was issued whereby they said it's better that we
3:193 minutes, 19 secondskill everyone than allow people to be captured now this was supposedly rescinded several years
3:243 minutes, 24 secondsago but at midday on October the 7th the Army revived the Hannibal directive put it into effect
3:323 minutes, 32 seconds70 Vehicles were hit at least in some of the cases everyone in the vehicle was killed the Israeli
3:383 minutes, 38 secondsmilitary does not deny the report the peculiarity of the days after October 7 is that the Israeli
3:463 minutes, 46 secondsmedia and subsequently the international media choose to focus not on the very real and extensive crimes that Hamas and others did commit but on crimes they did not commit and this had
3:563 minutes, 56 secondstwo focuses in the days immediately after it's to do with babies the most dramatic one is we see an allegation that there were 40 babies killed many of them beheaded this is very simple to deal with
4:074 minutes, 7 secondsbecause we have a comprehensive list of the Dead we know that two babies are killed on October the
4:134 minutes, 13 seconds7th one is an 10-month old child who is hit by a bullet fired through a safe room door the other
4:194 minutes, 19 secondsis a child who dies after a emergency cesarian a bedin child in fact now any story about babies
4:264 minutes, 26 secondsthat does not relate to those two and there are a lot lot of stories about babies is not true we
4:334 minutes, 33 secondsknow it's not true this has enormous implications for the other wave of atrocity stories that began
4:404 minutes, 40 secondsvery quickly which is to do with sexual violence and particularly the Israeli assertion that it
4:464 minutes, 46 secondswas widespread and systematic to be clear in the film we are not saying that there were no
4:514 minutes, 51 secondsrapes on October the 7th we simply don't know what we are saying is that there simply is not
4:574 minutes, 57 secondsthe evidence there's not the forensic evidence there's not the Visual Evidence there's not the photographic evidence and there is not the witness evidence to support the allegation
5:075 minutes, 7 secondsof widespread and systematic rape the Israelis have this strange system where they Farm out the
5:125 minutes, 12 secondscollection of bodies after disasters and terrorist attacks and so on to an organization called zacha
5:185 minutes, 18 secondswho are Ultra Orthodox religious volunteers they collect the bodies prepare them for religious
5:245 minutes, 24 secondsburial and so on a character that many people will have seen in the days afterwards is Yosi
5:295 minutes, 29 secondsland who was the southern commander of zacha who was on television a great deal he said two piles
5:365 minutes, 36 secondsof 10 children each were tied to the back burned to death you then see a phone call which Netanyahu
5:455 minutes, 45 secondsmakes to President Biden where he repeats this story in fact he embellishes it they took dozens
5:505 minutes, 50 secondsof children bound them up burned them and executed them terribly important this cuz it was entirely
5:585 minutes, 58 secondsuntrue we know the house he's talking about he's talking about the house in kibot ber which was the house that was stormed by Israeli police and military and where it is almost certain that all
6:086 minutes, 8 secondsof the hostages were killed by the Israeli police and military there were two children there two twins but no other children so we know the story is untrue Mr land told a number of other stories
6:186 minutes, 18 secondsthere's one particularly notorious one about the fetus being cut out of a pregnant woman the baby
6:236 minutes, 23 secondsthat was connected to the court was stabbed and she he was shot in the back we simply know this
6:316 minutes, 31 secondsis untrue the list of the Dead show there's no such victim Mr land said you know I have
6:376 minutes, 37 secondsa picture of this atrocity if you want to see the picture I have the picture of it this is the baby
6:426 minutes, 42 secondsI'm sorry to be graphic here but I I can't see a baby here you can't see the baby because but
6:486 minutes, 48 secondsthis is the picture of the of the mother it was a piece of charred flesh it wasn't a baby it certainly wasn't a baby so it was interesting and psychologically I'm not quite sure why he offered
6:586 minutes, 58 secondsto show me a photo that he did didn't have I'd point out as well that zacha was an organization that was in trouble there had been a major Scandal its founder had been accused of child sexual abuse
7:087 minutes, 8 secondsthere was a financial Scandal it had been found to be cooking the books it's raised an awful lot of money since October the 7th these stories were clearly useful and they were useful to the Israeli
7:197 minutes, 19 secondsgovernment in the film we see Benjamin Netanyahu visiting zaka volunteers and thanking them for
7:247 minutes, 24 secondstalking to the world's media and stressing that this is another front in the war when
7:367 minutes, 36 secondswhy does this matter why does it matter whether this type of atrocity was committed but not that type people were killed in this way not that way it matters because the murder of babies and
7:457 minutes, 45 secondswidespread rape has a particular resonance it's particularly triggering the Israeli government
7:517 minutes, 51 secondsand its supporters when they justify the brutality of the subsequent bombardment and invasion of the
7:577 minutes, 57 secondsGaza Strip again and again and again what they always reference is babies and rape young girls
8:048 minutes, 4 secondswho were raped and then murdered women brutally raped and murdered little kids who are beheaded
8:118 minutes, 11 secondspictures of terrorists beheading children these bastards put these babies in an oven and put on
8:178 minutes, 17 secondstheir oven we found the kid a few hours later this is something you see in previous conflicts as well
8:238 minutes, 23 secondsif you want to dehumanize an enemy if you want to desensitize people to the suffering that is inflicted on that enemy then you portray them as barbarians basically as Savages as people who are
8:348 minutes, 34 secondsnot deserving of Humane treatment and that's why it's relevant that's why it's important to pick apart a lot of the world's leading media Outlets have done in-depth investigations where they
8:448 minutes, 44 secondshave concluded there was widespread systematic instrumentalized weaponized rape the New York Times makes a particular feature of the story of a young woman she was killed early in the morning
8:548 minutes, 54 seconds9 miles north of the music festival site as she and her husband were fleeing the New York Times
9:009 minutesin its big December investigation into sexual violence leads with this and about a third of
9:079 minutes, 7 secondsthe article consists of her story and it's immediately undermined because the woman's sister then posts on Instagram immediately afterwards this isn't true we know she wasn't
9:169 minutes, 16 secondsraped she was texting us until minutes before her death it's also the case that her husband had a
9:219 minutes, 21 secondslengthy phone conversation immediately after her death with his brother and again made no mention
9:279 minutes, 27 secondsof rape so it's very important that because it's the central most compelling piece of information
9:339 minutes, 33 secondsin one of the biggest investigations done by one of the world's most prestigious media Outlets the
9:399 minutes, 39 secondsNew York Times and it turns out not to be true it's done by three journalists one of them turns out to be somebody who worked in some capacity for Israeli intelligence previously who has virtually
9:489 minutes, 48 secondsno journalistic experience and who had liked genocidal media posts it's very interesting with
9:559 minutes, 55 secondsAnna Schwartz she gives an interview in Hebrew to an Israeli Channel she actually lays out how
10:0110 minutes, 1 seconddifficult they were finding it to find evidence that they they were talking to all the hospitals and all the psychiatric clinics and so on and that there was simply no evidence at all there
10:1010 minutes, 10 secondswere no Witnesses had come forward no no victims had come forward at all I think she's telling this as if to show what digging they had to do but it's actually very revealing in the end it's
10:2010 minutes, 20 secondsquite clear they fall back on the same sources as everyone else Israeli government officials IDF
10:2510 minutes, 25 secondsofficers and First Responders all sources which were discredited by the baby stories so no babies
10:3310 minutes, 33 secondswere beheaded no babies were were thrown into ovens and there is no real evidence for widespread
10:4010 minutes, 40 secondsand systematic rape now it's very clear why the Israelis might want these stories to to circulate
10:4710 minutes, 47 secondswhat's less clear is why very reputable Western news and media Outlets should swallow them so
10:5410 minutes, 54 secondsuncritically particularly given the track record of the Israeli government and the idea which has
11:0011 minutesbeen shown again and again and again in the past to have been less than truthful in the accounts it
11:0511 minutes, 5 secondsgives because our war is against Hamas not against the people of Gaza while this mission is urgent we
11:1211 minutes, 12 secondswill continue to fulfill it with care and with a commitment to the sanctity of Life both Israeli
11:1811 minutes, 18 secondsand Palestinian the response to our film October the 7th has been interesting the response is not
11:2611 minutes, 26 secondsto criticize and to pick a part and say we've got it wrong uh they don't do that at all what they do is they simply ignore you which on one level I take as a compliment because I think there are
11:3411 minutes, 34 secondsall sorts of people out there who would very much like to pick apart what we're doing and to destroy it and discredit it and I think they take one look at it and decide they can't really do it so what
11:4311 minutes, 43 secondsthey do do which in a way is even more damaging is just to entirely ignore us this is significant
11:4911 minutes, 49 secondsbecause so often what we are doing is critiquing the way the mainstream media has covered the story which may well be of course precisely why the media doesn't want to look at what we we've
11:5911 minutes, 59 secondsdone so in a way the treatment of this in many ways Echoes the treatment of our earlier series the labor files which offered a critique of the dominant media narrative about Corbin and the
12:0912 minutes, 9 secondsCorbin years on the anti-Semitism crisis the allegation of anti-Semitism clearly is a very
12:1612 minutes, 16 secondspowerful weapon that can be wielded in defense of the Israeli State I think sometimes particularly
12:2212 minutes, 22 secondsby the Israel state is wielded very cynically and very deliberately when the ICC investigates Israel
12:2812 minutes, 28 secondsfor f war crimes this is pure anti-Semitism it's not the case in Western media and Western socities
12:3712 minutes, 37 secondsthat you cannot criticize Israel you can now you have to be a bit careful about how you do it but certainly at the moment during the assault on Gaza you certainly can what you cannot do is
12:4712 minutes, 47 secondsto question the fundamental philosophy of Zionism what you are not allowed to do is to say what all
12:5412 minutes, 54 secondsPalestinians would say Israel is a state whose defining feature is and has always been that it
13:0013 minutesis structured to ensure the domination of one ethnicity over another that it is in effect an aparte state which is what all of the world's human rights organizations now describe it as
13:1013 minutes, 10 secondsthe enormous peculiarity and dysfunction of Western media with Israel is not only does it not say that you're actually not allowed to say that and this renders criticism of Israel
13:2113 minutes, 21 secondsperilous terrain people are very on edge they're very aware that they're straying into dangerous
13:2713 minutes, 27 secondsterritory they're very aware they have to choose their words terribly carefully otherwise they will be misconstrued you can see this happening at its worst within the labor party where particularly
13:3713 minutes, 37 secondsJewish people are far far more likely to be suspended and expelled for anti-Semitism from the labor party the non-jewish people but there is something more fundamental that goes on which
13:4813 minutes, 48 secondsregards the Palestinian people as a whole once you have tainted them with the stain of anti-Semitism
13:5513 minutes, 55 secondsyou have opened the door to you have facilitated the dehumanization of Palestinians which is the
14:0214 minutes, 2 secondspsychological prerequisite of Israeli brutality towards the Palestinians and of Western complicity
14:0814 minutes, 8 secondsin that brutality Palestinians will often make the point that they did not choose who their occupier
14:1414 minutes, 14 secondswas who their colonizer was so in fighting back yes they are inevitably fighting back
14:2014 minutes, 20 secondsagainst zionists and Jews it doesn't mean they're anti-semitic one has to ask ones the question are we really saying that if they had been colonized by Greeks or Italians they wouldn't be resisting
14:3114 minutes, 31 secondstheir occupation of course they would 36 Israeli children were killed on October
14:3614 minutes, 36 secondsthe 7th and this understandably got widespread International media coverage at this stage I
14:4314 minutes, 43 secondsthink over 14,000 Palestinian children have been killed and you would expect the outrage and the
14:5114 minutes, 51 secondscoverage to be proportionately greater and it's not in future people will look back at what is
14:5714 minutes, 57 secondsbeing done which is essent the flattening of a whole series of towns and the mass murder
15:0315 minutes, 3 secondsof thousands and thousands of unarmed civilians almost half of whom are children and they will
15:0815 minutes, 8 secondsbe absolutely bewildered by How the West allowed this to happen under its very noses with weapons
15:1715 minutes, 17 secondsthat were being supplied by the West there is a rupture in the relationship of large numbers of
15:2215 minutes, 22 secondspeople with the political media class there is a fundamental alienation that is going on right
15:3015 minutes, 30 secondsnow as a result of what is happening in the Gaza Strip I think that's very dangerous for the future
15:3615 minutes, 36 secondsthe events of October the 7 are a case study in how traditional media can let us down and how
15:4315 minutes, 43 secondswe desperately need alternative voices that will genuinely probe these things and not simply accept
15:4915 minutes, 49 secondsthe narratives that are fed to them for this reason I think it's enormously important to have
15:5415 minutes, 54 secondsOutlets like Double Down News and I would urge you to support Double Down use in any way you can
===
No comments:
Post a Comment