(1) Facebook
Sinai Project
19 hours ago ·
Hagai Lober, father of late Staff Sergeant Yonatan Lober who fell in Gaza, responded on Radio 'Galei Israel' to an anti-Israel NGO film: "I think the greatest difficulty with this film, or with these claims in general, is that right from the start they force you into a playing field that dictates IDF soldiers must risk their lives so fewer enemy civilians, or even enemy terrorists, are killed, and so homes aren't destroyed."
"My son was killed because of a targeted operation, because they sent them to fight-as the investigation also shows—they sent them on a surgical operation inside homes and alleyways. Fire was opened on him from high, controlling buildings, which were later, of course, blown up. I have no claims whatsoever, not even a shadow of a claim, against Yonatan's direct commanders. They acted sharply, decisively, professionally, and protected my son's life and everyone's lives in the best possible way. But those were the tools they were given. Those were the missions.
My son is the collateral damage of these miserable decisions. It was strictly forbidden to enter there without first flattening the entire surrounding area. We are a bereaved family, we cry every day. Yonatan's children are growing up without their biological father... this damage could have been prevented".
Zak Polo
·
These conflicts don't happen in a vacuum. You have to keep logically going back in steps to figure out, why these people are resisting in the first place.
Sinai Project
19 hours ago ·
Hagai Lober, father of late Staff Sergeant Yonatan Lober who fell in Gaza, responded on Radio 'Galei Israel' to an anti-Israel NGO film: "I think the greatest difficulty with this film, or with these claims in general, is that right from the start they force you into a playing field that dictates IDF soldiers must risk their lives so fewer enemy civilians, or even enemy terrorists, are killed, and so homes aren't destroyed."
"My son was killed because of a targeted operation, because they sent them to fight-as the investigation also shows—they sent them on a surgical operation inside homes and alleyways. Fire was opened on him from high, controlling buildings, which were later, of course, blown up. I have no claims whatsoever, not even a shadow of a claim, against Yonatan's direct commanders. They acted sharply, decisively, professionally, and protected my son's life and everyone's lives in the best possible way. But those were the tools they were given. Those were the missions.
My son is the collateral damage of these miserable decisions. It was strictly forbidden to enter there without first flattening the entire surrounding area. We are a bereaved family, we cry every day. Yonatan's children are growing up without their biological father... this damage could have been prevented".
Zak Polo
·
These conflicts don't happen in a vacuum. You have to keep logically going back in steps to figure out, why these people are resisting in the first place.
Could it be someone invaded their land?
Reply
Zak Polo it can be also religiously motivated
Reply
Zak Polo could it be that radical Islam wants the Middle East all for themselves?!?!
Reply
·
Chana Rosenthal Baron So. Would that be an "existential threat" Father?
Reply
Ooogaa it sure sounds like one to me!
Reply
·
Chana Rosenthal Baron Explain please.
Reply
Blake Singer How can people invade a land they've lived in as long as we have recorded history?
Reply
Zak Polo that wasn’t what happened. Jews have been living on THAT land for thousands of years so how does one colonize land we’ve been living on? And how do we know it was Jewish land? Because the archaeological finds are Jewish and Roman. Romans brutally colonized the land from the Jews.
Reply
Ray Fletcher YES! The truth!
Reply
Tony Cizek Everything is Israel's fault. That's a tidy narrative to avoid responsibility.
Reply
Stacey Drucker, the Greater Israel Project is a fact.
Reply
Reply
Tony Cizek let me get this straight. There are 7 MILLION Jews in Israel and that 7 MILLION has destabilized 2 BILLION Muslims? Do you believe that?
Reply
Zak Polo, were the twin towers in Manhattan also on Islamic land?
Reply
Zak Polo what about the October 7th invasion of Israel
Reply
Zak Polo how could Israel invade Israeli territory?
Reply
Zak Polo Great News!!! Today’s United Nations announcement on the Western Hemisphere is a game changer!
ALL the countries of North, Central, & South America (Canada, USA, Mexico, Panama, Brazil, Argentina, etc etc) are ALL dissolving their nationhood and will no longer be occupying & ethnically cleansing the American continents! Their brutal apartheid rule is OVER!!
They are all restoring the governance of the Americas to the indigenous peoples pre 1492!
Zak!! Great minds think alike!
ANYONE with European, African, & Asian ancestry are being given 12 months to return to the lands of their forefathers!
After that Israelis will have NO EXCUSE not to do the same!
Exciting days ahead!
Reply
Zak Polo no based on history.
Reply
Zak Polo the article is about whether soldiers should use the very high-risk approach by searching surgically for the enemy/terrorist/Hamas OR the far safer approach of flattening the structure/location of the enemy. The father is of a soldier killed using the more dangerous approach.
Don’t use the article as your chance to bring up “you did that first,” “no you did that first” debate. That back and forth has no end and if you’ve followed this topic more than a few months you would know that very well.
Since you asked, no it wasn’t “their land.” Today’s Palestinian identity did not exist in ‘48. Maybe 1970-something. They may have had their village, town, or home but no national identity. A Palestinian living in Ramallah from ‘48 -‘67 lived in part of Jordan. One in Gaza, was part of Egypt. They didn’t resist against Jordan or Egypt being on “their land” for their own state. Why is that?
Let’s see, from you, some that logic you mentioned by answering my question
Reply
Edited
"Most relevant" is selected, so some replies may have been filtered out.
That's a confusing wording. It was forbidden to flatten before entering, or was it forbidden to enter before flattening?
Reply
God forever blesses Israel his children of Abraham Isaac and Jacob in yeshua Messiah amen
Reply
Oh sorry for the loss . May his good soul rest in the bossom of the Lord , may the Lord grant this family the fortitude to bear the loss. You'll be stronger again in Jesus Christ mighty name. Amen 
Reply
May his memory be a blessing.
God bless you & your family
Reply
May his memory forever be a blessing 
Reply
May God grant everything to these people that they do unto others, may they receive what they wish for others and be treated the same as they treat others. May their children be treated the same as they treat others and their neighbours treat them as they treat their neighbours. Amen 
Reply
·
I think you mean "clearing" the area and not "flattening"
Reply
Please double check your translation.
Reply
RIP Amen Salute
Amen SaluteReply
May his memory be for ever a blessing. So sorry for your loss.
Love from Chile
Reply
God confort Family and Israel 
Reply
아버지, 당신은 가장 높은 이스라엘에 올라가신, 위에서부터 가족, 친구, 우리 군인들, 그리고 이스라엘 국가를 보호하는 용감한 영웅이시니 축복받으시기를 바랍니다. 우리는 결코 우리의 아들과 딸들을 잊지 않을 것입니다, 아멘 Reply
See original (Hebrew)
No comments:
Post a Comment