Monday, October 26, 2026

the specific story of "Avdar Shailovski" fleeing to Poland and penning a viral denunciation is entirely made up.

Facebook


대니얼 레스토 (Daniel Resto) 10월 25일 23:10

이스라엘군(IDF) 안에도 인간성과 양심을 지닌 군인이 드디어 나타났다고 생각했던 바로 그 순간, 이 글이 가짜라는 사실이 밝혀졌다. 간단한 팩트체크를 통해 확인된 내용은 다음과 같다.

소셜 미디어 특정 그룹과 일부 비주류 블로그를 중심으로 퍼지고 있는 이 화제의 글은 허위 사실을 유포하기 위해 지어낸 가상의 인물에 기반하고 있다. 지난 세월 동안 실제 이스라엘 예비군들이 다양한 정치적·전략적 우려를 표명하며 서명한 정당하고 기록으로 남겨진 항의 성명이나 공개 서한들은 분명히 존재했으나, <압다르 샤일롭스키(Avdar Shailovski)>라는 인물이 폴란드로 탈출하여 공개 규탄글을 작성했다는 이 구체적인 이야기는 전적으로 날조된 것이다.

우리는 이스라엘군과 범죄적인 이스라엘이라는 국가가 얼마나 끔찍한지 보여주기 위해 굳이 이야기를 꾸며낼 필요가 없다. 눈과 귀, 그리고 뇌가 있는 사람이라면 누구나 그 증거를 분명히 알 수 있다! 거짓말을 지어내거나 가짜 정보를 공유하면 우리 스스로가 그들과 똑같이 보일 뿐이다. 다들 똑바로 행동하자!

https://www.facebook.com/daniel.resto.3/posts/pfbid0q8WJfs3twGWW1evn1CmqngbtxBkshNLuGw5BDn5qmDdsbuwkSfuNAu3nQbk4Ksnwl

---

댓글에는:

<피오나 마리사 (Fiona Marissa)>

공유해 주셔서 감사합니다. 이제 제가 올렸던 글도 삭제하고 정정해야겠네요.

<주디 밀스 (Judy Mills)>

이 글이 가짜라는 당신의 게시물을 여러 그룹에 공유했습니다. 이 가짜 글을 소개하는 꽤 많은 게시물에도 제가 직접 댓글을 달아두었고요. 이 글이 참상을 계속 부각하고 일어나는 일에 "신빙성을 부여"하려는 좌파나 친팔레스타인 또는 반시오니스트 그룹에 의해 만들어진 것인지, 아니면 시온주의자나 우파 측에서 의도적으로 허위 정보를 퍼뜨려 상대방을 "합법적으로" 깎아내리고 '이 거짓말들을 봐라, 저쪽은 온통 프로파간다투성이니 믿지 마라'고 말하려는 것인지는 모르겠습니다. 어느 쪽이든, 우리 모두가 이 내용이 사실이어서 우리의 입장을 정당화해 주기를 바란다 할지라도, 언제나 팩트체크가 우선입니다. 그렇지 않으면 우리 스스로 신뢰를 잃게 되니까요. 양측 모두 상대방을 조롱할 때 흔히 써먹는 일이죠.

<대니얼 레스토 (Daniel Resto / 작성자)>

<주디 밀스> 저를 나쁘게 보이게 만들려고 시온주의자들이 꾸민 짓이라고 생각합니다.

<주디 밀스 (Judy Mills)>

<대니얼 레스토> 방금 제가 공유했던 것들을 전부 삭제해야 했습니다. 왜냐하면 당신이 가짜라고 쓴 글이 아니라 원본 게시물(OOP)만 그대로 공유되고 있었다는 걸 알아차렸거든요! 다른 사람들도 똑같이 해서 사태를 더 키운 건 아닌지 모르겠습니다.


Just when I thought there was a member of the IDF with humanity and decency, it turns out this post is fake. Here's what a simple fact-check turned up.
* * *
The viral post, which primarily circulates in specific social media groups and fringe blogs, relies on a fictional name to spread misinformation. While there have been legitimate, well-documented protests and open letters signed by actual Israeli military reservists expressing various political or strategic concerns over the years, the specific story of "Avdar Shailovski" fleeing to Poland and penning a viral denunciation is entirely made up.
* * *
Look, we don't NEED to make shit up to show how horrible the IDF and the criminal state of israel are. The proof is obvious to anyone with eyes, ears, and a brainstem! When we make up lies or share false information, we make ourselves look as bad as them.
DO BETTER, PEOPLE!


Israeli Reserve Major Avdar Shailovski wrote an article, which he published on his Facebook page, recounting his flight from the Israeli military and his emigration from Israel to Poland—the land of his ancestors.
The article is titled: "I Can No Longer Remain Silent."
Here is the full text of the article:
I am Avdar Shailovski, a major who deserted the Israeli military. I declare, while of sound mind, that I left the Israeli military because I could no longer bear to remain a silent witness—betraying my own humanity—to all the crimes I witnessed during my five years of service.
The events I witnessed will suffocate me if I do not share them with you.
I could die at any moment from the sheer weight of my grief; therefore, I must contribute to revealing the truth—perhaps it will alleviate my sense of guilt, and perhaps God will lessen the torment that awaits me for the horrific acts I committed simply by virtue of being a member of the Israel Defense Forces.
Then, I received a sign: "Leave everything behind and go your own way."
Thank You, God, for guiding me.
As soon as the El Al flight landed at Warsaw Airport, I felt safe—far away from the land of Israel, which no longer holds any meaning for me.
They taught us about the land that God promised us, but it is the greatest lie ever used to deceive the Jewish people. It is a persistent, ongoing lie—one that has continued around the clock for eighty years—which has resulted in the displacement of an unarmed Palestinian people from their own land. Furthermore, to this very day, these people continue to suffer immensely. Who invented this lie? And what kind of "foolish" people believed it?
What I witnessed during my five-year service in the Israel Defense Forces (IDF) is difficult to put into words.
What words could possibly describe the cruelty, the vileness, and the atrocities committed by the IDF against the Palestinians?
Do not believe a word from that wretched man—that scoundrel, son of a scoundrel. He is a despicable liar, especially when he claims the Israeli army is "the most moral army in the world"—what utter nonsense! The truth is, it is the most depraved, cruel, and brutal army in the world.
Yes, ladies and gentlemen, I can no longer bear to witness the ruin and destruction in Gaza.
I was a witness to what took place on the night of October 7, 2023. Israeli intelligence, that wretched man, and his gang knew it was coming; they waited for it to happen so they could justify the destruction of Gaza and attempt to displace its population.
I served in Gaza, and I saw with my own eyes how a tank commander would toy with his tank’s cannon, firing shells at Palestinians huddled inside their tents, or at groups of people standing in lines—whether in front of bakeries, or by vehicles distributing food and aid. With my own eyes, I witnessed aircraft firing projectiles at inhabited residential buildings, reducing them to rubble atop the people living inside.
With my own eyes, I saw snipers from the occupation army amusing themselves by picking off children, adults, and women as they stood in line to receive aid.
This is madness.
Crimes such as these—which I witnessed—could not happen anywhere else in the world; they occur only on the land of Palestine.
With my own eyes, I saw a child clutching a piece of stale, blood-soaked bread, weeping over his mother’s body—while the soldiers laughed, as if they were watching a comedy video.
They claim that these people are not human beings, not equals to us—to us Jews.
I would summon my courage and say to my colleagues, "Brother, even if they were a group of monkeys, could we possibly kill them in this manner?"
They would reply, "You are a coward; you are weak—you are not fit to be a Jew."
I saw settlers in the West Bank uprooting olive trees and assaulting farmers in their own fields.
I saw them destroy homes—issuing an immediate evacuation order to the owners, only to demolish the structures while the residents were still inside.
With my own eyes, I saw a soldier send a text message to a Palestinian, telling him: "Go up to the roof, or we will destroy the house—with your family inside—because of you." When the man climbed to the roof and began waving a white rag, the soldier shot him dead on the spot.
Can anyone believe this? I can find no explanation for all this Israeli cruelty other than the upbringing we Jews were subjected to. We were told that Arabs are filthy, savage, and extremist Muslim killers—and that if we were kind to them, they would throw us into the sea. Just imagine the kind of indoctrination they fed us.
They taught us that the land of Palestine belongs to us, the Jews.
They claimed that the Golan and the entire Levant belong to the children of Zion.
They taught us that "Greater Israel" stretches from the Euphrates to the Nile.
How wicked we Jews must be to believe all these lies. If we were not wicked, foolish, and devoid of morality, we would never have carried out these orders.
I can no longer bear to witness these atrocities.
At night, I would weep, while my colleagues mocked me, calling me a coward. They insisted that a Jew should be obsessed with killing Arabs and ridding the Promised Land of them.
I pray for a day when the Arabs wake up and realize that Israel is an illusion—a lie—that will eventually vanish. Were it not for their own leaders, who collude with the criminal Netanyahu and his gang, we would never have been able to commit the crimes and atrocities we have perpetrated.
Forgive me, O Lord, for everything we have done to the innocent Palestinians.
Forgive me, O God, for the atrocities we have committed.
As the Muslims say, You are "Most Forgiving, Most Merciful." I trust that You will forgive me, now that I have found my way after having been lost.
Thank You, O God, for guiding me to the straight path—
the path of truth, love, and peace—far removed from the path of the criminal state of Israel.
Translated from English by Nasser Al-Maghout.
Thanks for sharing. Now I’ve got to delete & retract.
  • Reply
  • I've shared your post about it being a fake to several groups. I must have commented on a fair few posts that offer this fake post out. I do not know whether it's been created by left or pro-palestinian or anti-zionist group to try and keep the atrocities at the forefront and "give credibility" to what is happening, or if it's from Zionists or the right purposely spreading disinformation so they can "legitimately" discredit the other side and say look at these lies, the other side is full of propaganda don't believe it." Either way, as much as we'd all like it to be true and validate our stance, always fact check first, otherwise we do lose credibility. Something which both sides are happy to mock the other for.
  • Reply
  • Edited
  •  
     
    Author
    Judy Mills I think it's the Zionists attempting to make us look bad.
  • Reply
  • Daniel Resto I've just had to delete all my shares, because I've realised that it's just posting the OOP and not yours saying it's fake! 🤦‍♀️ I wonder if others have done the same and it's exacerbated it.
  • Reply

  • No comments:

    Post a Comment

    Kenya's ghost writers help students abroad... - BBC World Service | Facebook

    (2) Kenya's ghost writers help students abroad... - BBC World Service | Facebook BBC World Service  · Kenya's ghost writers help stu...